'Clean' Gains, Creatine, and Why You Aren't Eating Enough (2024)

Hello, beautiful people!

If you’re new here, welcome, and thank you so much for joining my new-to-me adventure of writing about nutrition when I’m not busy cooking it for a living. It’s summer here in Phoenix, and similar to winter back home in the snowy North Woods, it’s a horrible time to be alive - and a fantastic time to bear down and get our collective sh*t together. For me, this means getting back to a regimented fitness routine - and as a person who makes a living cooking for professional athletes, a fitness routine means a diet routine to support it. Fear not, this is not a gym-bro post - I deadlift in socks and wear Birkenstocks to the gym - but we do need to discuss nutritional starvation, dehydration, and why you’re probably eating too much of the wrong thing and not enough of the right, plus how to reset if you want to, or just add some more goodness into your daily eating habits. This is a fly-over - I’m not totally sure how interested my audience is about sports nutrition, so I kept it short. I’m happy to write way more about it anytime.

When people think about sports nutrition, I can almost guarantee that what comes to mind is in powdered form, and nothing about it gets the salivary glands moving. Sports nutrition, for the most part, absolutely f*cking sucks - white rice, chicken breast and steamed broccoli feels like hospital food and punishment, while the onslaught of mystery powders, abbreviations and “must haves” stops most folks from trying at all. Let’s get a few things out of the way first before we get into the big concepts.

If you’ve read some other articles, you know I loathe the term “clean” eating - it calls forth a tradwife churning raw milk ice cream in a trust fund mansion and it rests in the realm of shame - clean suggests the existence of dirty, and while we can make good or better choices based on our access to healthier foods, the term can be improved to contain empathy for the variety of situations which prevent a human being from accessing them the same way we do. I use “whole” and “unprocessed” in place of “clean” when talking about ingredients I prefer to use in my personal life and my work. The terms “clean gains” or “clean bulk” are industry wide references to how you eat to gain muscle weight - clean bulk vs. dirty bulk means counting macros + eating whole foods vs. gobbling up Reeces Pieces to hit your daily caloric goal. I had a bodybuilding trainer years ago who would eat a sleeve of them to “hit his numbers.” That example is extreme but it certainly paints a picture. Let’s make this the last time we use the word clean, and shift our focus from calories to where the calories are.

Most of my friends, as well as my clients, do not eat anywhere close to enough, do not drink anywhere near enough water, and skew their dietary ratios towards joy and away from function - regardless of their fitness habits or goals. Food is a beautiful, happy, uniting thing - and it’s also our fuel source, or medicine, and a necessary vehicle for greater health and strength. The chronic malnutrition many of us experience due to poor time management and dopamine chasing eating habits contribute to loss of cognitive function, organ function, bone density and digestive health. In no way am I suggesting that we should remove the joy - but we need to be honest with ourselves about our health, and if we’re eating for dopamine or for longevity (ideally, both). If you are not interested in using food as an instrumental part of your fitness, and/or if you are not interested in food being your source of minerals, proteins, fats and carbohydrates in a way that adds up to what you actually need, then this article may not be for you (but you should still consider reading it).

At some point in your journey, you might’ve used a macro calculator or formula to determine your TDEE (total daily energy expenditure), aka the more or less foolproof baseline math for how many calories you need to consume to maintain your weight as is based on your activity level. There are zillions of calculators online for this purpose, but this one generally has no ads or extra clicks so I recommend starting here. If you select ‘maintain weight’ and are actually honest about your activity level, you’ll find your caloric intake for simply existing. Now, if you’re a highly active individual - a runner, a lifter, a daily yogi or pilates person, a hiker, whatever - your caloric intake goes up. In my practice, I work with a slightly different equation - focused on lean muscle gain - and you can find that calculator plus a really great write-up on what they mean and how they differ from traditional macro gaining here. Once you get your numbers, you can input them into your macro logging app, and start working towards your goal. Calories and exact numbers absolutely don’t have to rule your life - but if you feel helpless in where to begin, this is my recommendation - figuring out what amount of food you need to maintain is a great starting point for ensuring you’re getting enough nutrition before we start talking about loss, gain, or goals.

To give you some idea, I’m 31, 5’5, and 140 lbs. I am interested in lean gains, so I need about 1700 calories per day to maintain, and a little over 2,000 to gain. If you are not significantly underweight or overweight in a manner which raises medical concern, I would recommend taking a week or two to eat your TDEE recommendation and see how you feel. This is what I do with clients new to tracking. Here’s looking at you, three cold brews and a sweet treat for breakfast and lunch - your bones are deteriorating, stop it. I am not here to tell you how to lose weight unless you hire me to do so - diet culture and weight loss culture are evil, flat stomachs are often genetic and plastic surgery has destroyed genuine fitness physique as something to reference on the internet - but if you want to change your body, work out efficiently, recover well and grow muscle, and as a cherry on top start to lose some excess body fat, you should first start with making sure you are eating enough, and enough of the right thing.

Where your calories split is what matters. How much protein, fat, and carbohydrates you need to eat every day come down to math and personal preference, but mostly math. I like a high protein diet, so I’m slamming 170g protein every day, and splitting the fat/carbs 50%. One week of eating like this makes my deadlifts heavier, my recovery faster, and my stamina higher. If you are not willing to hit your required nutritional goals, do not bother weightlifting. You are setting yourself up for injury, fatigue and malnutrition - aesthetics have nothing to do with it. We also have to learn to track our vitamins and minerals, because we don’t get as many as we think. Your giant bowl of salad barely touches half of what you think it does - whereas a few cups of cooked spinach satisfy a majority of your daily requirements. I really, really, really urge you to download Cronometer - it’s free - do not pay for anything extra - and start logging your food. Where I really move the needle for my clients is when we start making better choices for what we eat in these categories, with minerals in mind. Some examples:

I think it goes without saying that restrictive diets do not work, as we are autonomous beings and we need to experience reward sensations from the activities we take part in throughout the day. But we’re also addicted to dopamine, from TikTok to Instagram to snacks, and this is where you can start to make changes. I think where people misstep comes down to a few things :

  • A lack of planning - trying to make something to eat while hungry is horrible. It also leads to eating out most of the time. Having multiple options, prepped and ready, portioned for bonus points will make nutrition forward eating much easier. I plan my week ahead of time

  • Carb dominant eating habits - carbs are delicious. They’re also addictive. A few weeks of counting your macros and weighing your food will shine a very bright light on where your normal diet is imbalanced and give you an opportunity for correction. Carbs aren’t bad, I think keto people are maniacs (I say that with love, but when I tried it and entered ketosis I thought I was dying, so no thanks), but eating mostly carbs and then doubling down with potato and corn based snacks while totally under-eating proteins and fats is simply not the way

  • Not actually counting - it’s incredibly important to weigh your food when you’re participating in an assessment or a precision diet like this. This means buying a little digital scale, and weighing every single thing you eat - you will be absolutely shocked at what you find. Cronometer is my go to tool for logging your daily meals or planning them ahead of time, and it has in-depth vitamin and mineral values that are extraordinarily educational as we restructure our relationships with what we eat

  • Leaving no room for fun - stop calling it a cheat day. It’s a regular day. You’re just taking a break from a super disciplined and regimented thing you’re in the middle of. I think 5 days of super intentional eating and two days of slightly less intentional eating are the key split - it doesn’t mean gorging on Doritos and ice cream all day, but it does man loosening up and eating whatever you want with intention to honor the work you’ve been doing

  • If weightlifting, adequate creatine supplementation

A quick note on creatine: if you lift heavy stuff and set it back down, and your kidneys, liver, and blood pressure are healthy, you need to add creatine to your roster. You know I hate unnecessary supplements, so it takes a lot for me to recommend something - but y’all, it is night and day as far as muscle growth, performance and recovery. It also significantly contributes to your bone density and your brain health. No, creatine doesn’t make you fat, no, you don’t need to load it, no, it’s not gross, and no, it doesn’t mean you have to drink two gallons of water. Creatine exists in our body and supplies power to our muscles as they expand and contract. Your body makes about 1g of creatine a day, and while you do get some from meat and fish, everyone with a love for lifting can benefit from supplementation. I use this one from Kion, as I trust their products and sourcing - you can use whatever you want, just make sure it’s a monohydrate. I really recommend Kion, though, for creatine, aminos, and colostrum - I would skip the protein powder and opt for a more cost effective one. And while we’re on the subject, if you can get your protein in without protein powder, you should. Whole foods are always better. But if you’re going to use a protein, whey isolate or bone broth proteins are what I prefer and what my athletes use. This is my preferred BBP. Bone broth protein is elite due to its glycine content, as well as its complete amino acid profile and its ability to support collagen building in the body, increasing gastric secretion and serving as a superstar joint and bone supplement. Remember that many toxins are stored in the bones, so opt for a grass fed, organic option if you can.

You are dehydrated. Like, seriously, I am almost positive that 90% of folks reading this article are dehydrated. A doctor I trust with my life once told me that your minimum water consumption for the day is half your weight in pounds in ounces, and I try to drink 1.5x that every day (I also sweat like crazy in hot yoga and live in a very hot desert). Water is essential for every single function in our body so for the love of god, drink enough of it. Just start with a half gallon a day and see how you feel.

If this article feels like information overload, I get it. The hardest part of starting a new routine or lifestyle is the overwhelming amount of information on the internet telling you three thousand different things. Knowing where to start can be intimidating, and I encourage you to calculate your TDEE, download Cronometer and just start logging what you already eat. I have no kickback to this thing, I have no kickbacks to anything - it’s just a really useful application and it helps a lot of people live a lot healthier. Take time to read the values for your minerals, omegas, everything - and notice where you’re over and under. I really, really encourage everybody to make one choice today to introduce more fiber or produce into your life. Buy a bag of garbanzo beans, cook them in your crock pot and eat 4oz per day. Your digestion will be renewed. Buy a few bunches of spinach or kale and cook them with garlic and chicken stock, and eat a few ounces. It doesn’t take much. My grocery list for the week is as follows:

  • 6# organic chicken breast

  • 3# wild caught sockeye salmon

  • 1# organic dry garbanzo beans

  • 2# organic dry quinoa

  • 4 x organic kale bunch

  • 4 x organic spinach bunch

  • 18ct organic, pastured eggs

  • 1# organic sheep’s milk feta

  • 2 bottles almond malk (to use with frozen blueberries, creatine, protein powders, etc I already have)

  • 2 cucumbers

  • 4 avocados

  • 2 # brussel sprouts

  • mangoes, kiwis, whatever looks good

It’s an incredibly simple list. I prep my proteins, hard boil my eggs, prep my beans + grains, portion them out and always have something to eat. I feel incredibly strong. You can, too. If it’s something you want professional help with, I’m more than happy to oblige - but you are powerful, and you can take these steps yourself, too. As much as this is a sports nutrition post, eating enough of the right things is necessary for everybody - you don’t have to be an athlete to treat your body like the infinite strength source it is.

Over the next few months, I’ll be working on and publishing an e-book for a very intentional eating plan that will reshape your relationship with food over the course of thirty days. It will, like everything else on my Substack, focus on whole food integration, maximizing your caloric value, and how to prep like a professional chef. A lot of the subjects covered in this flyover will be emphasized there, so look out for that sometime this fall! I should also note that if you’re looking for somebody to write you a custom meal plan, put you on a thirty day re-set and help you with recipes and grocery lists to that goal, that’s literally what I do for a living. For about $100/month, I can build you a super custom meal plan + program and check in with you weekly as we navigate your goals - this is my job - I don’t like making this Substack super money-driven but I do suppose it’s worth mentioning. If you’re interested in that service, please e-mail me at mamachkapopup@gmail.com <3

I hope you drink lots of water today and get one step closer to learning how many calories your body needs, and how to hit those numbers with foods that nurture your bones, your belly and your muscles. It doesn’t have to be complicated, expensive, or difficult - it can come down to lentils, spinach and chicken breast for as long as you want. I promise. I just want you all to live forever.

In Health,

Anna

'Clean' Gains, Creatine, and Why You Aren't Eating Enough (2024)

FAQs

Can creatine cause lack of appetite? ›

It is also important to note that the effects of creatine on appetite can vary between individuals. For some people, optimal intakes may lead to increased satiety and reduced hunger, while others may experience increased hunger due to increased energy expenditure.

Why am I not seeing gains from creatine? ›

Some people just don't respond to creatine—it's a genetic thing. If you've started taking creatine, you should know if it works for you in about a week. If your training volume increases, it's working for you. If not, you're probably a non-responder, and taking the powder isn't going to help you.

Why am I not getting bigger with creatine? ›

Creatine can boost your energy stores and increase your athletic performance, but it may cause some water weight gain. Fluid retention might be temporary, or it might continue for as long as you use creatine. However, it may become less noticeable as you build lean muscle mass.

Why am I not gaining weight with creatine? ›

You have to consume more calories than you expend to gain fat. One scoop of creatine per day (about 5 grams) doesn't have any calories, or at the very least, only a few calories. If you stay active and eat a healthy diet, you're not likely to put on fat while using oral creatine.

Do you need to eat a lot of food when taking creatine? ›

You can also consume creatine if you eat normally, you do not need to eat extra. Calorie intake and creatine are not connected. once your muscle tissues increase, eventually you gain some more weight too.

Why am I losing weight on creatine? ›

But how exactly does combining creatine supplementation with resistance training lead to reduced fat? One idea is that increased muscle mass can increase your basal metabolic rate. With your body burning more calories at rest (and during exercise as well), fat loss may be more likely.

How to tell if creatine is working? ›

While individual responses may differ, several signs can indicate creatine is working: Increased Strength. One of the earliest signs of creatine's impact is often increased strength during resistance training. You might be able to lift heavier weights or perform more reps than before.

How quickly does creatine make you look bigger? ›

But if you choose the loading protocol, you'll see this initial weight spike during the first 7 days of using creatine. Whereas if you use the non-loading protocol, your weight will instead gradually increase over a period of 2-3 weeks until your muscles are fully saturated.

How much water should I drink on creatine? ›

You should take each 5-gram dose of creatine with at least 8 ounces of water. As for total daily water intake, you should aim for 3 to 4 liters, or 12 to 16 cups, per day. Remember: 1 L equals 1000 ml of water and 1 cup equals 8 ounces of fluid.

Can you look lean on creatine? ›

The truth is creatine does not directly impact body weight, but it can indirectly help you stay lean by increasing lean muscle mass and decreasing fat mass. Creatine supports muscle synthesis by providing energy for more power and strength during high-intensity exercise, which results in bigger muscles over time.

How do I maximize my creatine gains? ›

It's possible to maximize your muscle stores of creatine gradually over several weeks. However, the fastest way to maximize your muscle stores is a weeklong loading phase followed by lower doses to maintain high levels.

Does drinking more water on creatine make you bigger? ›

Drinking more water while taking creatine can enhance muscle hydration and cell volumization, potentially making muscles appear larger and fuller. However, true muscle growth depends on a combination of factors including nutrition, exercise, and overall protein synthesis, not just hydration and creatine intake.

Why am I not seeing results from creatine? ›

Although most pre-workouts contain creatine, many (if not all) underdose the ingredient. Taking only 1-2 grams of creatine in your pre-workout is hardly enough to see any benefit—the suggested dose is 5 grams. If you don't take your pre-workout on a daily basis, you're even more likely to miss out on gains.

Are creatine gains permanent? ›

The muscle gains from creatine can be both temporary or for the long term, depending on a variety of factors like consistency with training and nutrition over time. But the initial gain in weight during the first couple weeks of creatine supplementation are usually temporary.

Does creatine make you look puffy? ›

Creatine side effects

Actually, the phenomenon is so common it's earned a nickname, "the creatine bloat". But while creatine supplementation can lead to a slightly bloated appearance, it does not always — and if you dose the supplement properly, you can avoid this unwanted symptom altogether, Sims says.

Does creatine reduce cravings? ›

Appetite Regulation: While not directly linked to creatine's physiological effects, some individuals report experiencing appetite suppression or better appetite control with creatine supplementation. This subjective benefit can indirectly support weight loss efforts by reducing calorie intake and curbing cravings.

What happens to your body when you take creatine everyday? ›

Creatine is possibly safe when taken long-term. Doses up to 10 grams daily for up to 5 years have been safely used. Side effects might include dehydration, upset stomach, and muscle cramps.

Does creatine cause energy loss? ›

Creatine creates “quick burst” energy and increased strength, which improves your performance without affecting your ability to exercise for longer periods (aerobic endurance). Most athletes who take creatine supplements participate in power sports, including: Bodybuilding. Football.

Why take creatine on an empty stomach? ›

Taking creatine on an empty stomach is a personal choice and depends on individual preferences and tolerance. While it is safe for most people, some may experience digestive discomfort, and the absorption may not be as efficient as when taken with carbohydrates.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Maia Crooks Jr

Last Updated:

Views: 6042

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Maia Crooks Jr

Birthday: 1997-09-21

Address: 93119 Joseph Street, Peggyfurt, NC 11582

Phone: +2983088926881

Job: Principal Design Liaison

Hobby: Web surfing, Skiing, role-playing games, Sketching, Polo, Sewing, Genealogy

Introduction: My name is Maia Crooks Jr, I am a homely, joyous, shiny, successful, hilarious, thoughtful, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.